Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 1 Pending
1 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 2 Pending
2 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 3 Pending
3 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 4 Pending
4 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 5 Pending
5 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 6 Pending
6 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 7 Pending
7 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 8 Pending
8 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 9 Pending
9 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 10 Pending
10 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 11 Pending
11 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 12 Pending
12 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 13 Pending
13 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 14 Pending
14 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 15 Pending
15 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 16 Pending
16 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 17 Pending
17 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 18 Pending
18 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 19 Pending
19 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 20 Pending
20 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 21 Pending
21 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 22 Pending
22 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 23 Pending
23 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 24 Pending
24 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 25 Pending
25 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 26 Pending
26 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 27 Pending
27 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 28 Pending
28 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 29 Pending
29 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 30 Pending
30 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 31 Pending
31 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 32 Pending
32 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 33 Pending
33 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 34 Pending
34 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 35 Pending
35 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 36 Pending
36 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 37 Pending
37 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 38 Pending
38 / 39
Residential at 5714 Mutters Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876 — photo 39 Pending
39 / 39
Pending
$187,500

5714 N Mutters Road Stone Lake, WI 54876

2 beds · 1 bath · 1,232 sqft · $152/sqft · 5.41 acres · Built 1989

MLS# 1600141

About 5714 N Mutters Road

Hard to find modern, cute cabin surrounded by lakes and woods, not far from Stone Lake and City of Hayward.

Awesome large deck off the living room overlooks your very private 5 acres, with plenty of room to roam and possibly room for a pole building.

Seasonal views overlooking two lakes, including premier Sand Lake which has a boat launch .5 miles away.

You will love the extra space in the lower level with a walkout! This provides so many options for you! Enjoy Life North of the Tension Zone on this fabulous 5 acre jewel in Stone Lake!

Property Details

Style
One Story
Stories
1
Levels
One
Above Grade Finished
616 sq ft
Lot Dimensions
960 x 275 x 625 x 405
Possession
Close Of Escrow
Heating
Forced Air
Cooling
Central Air
Electric
Circuit Breakers
Water
Drilled Well
Sewer
Septic Tank
Foundation
Block
Construction
Composite Siding
Appliances
Dryer, Gas Water Heater, Oven, Range, Refrigerator, Water Softener, Washer
Basement
Full, Walk Out Access
Patio & Porch
Deck
Parking
Driveway, Gravel, No Garage
HOA
None
School District
Hayward Community
County
Sawyer
Township
Town of Sand Lake
Directions
Hwy 27 South of Hayward to East on Hwy 70. Turn right on Hwy F, to right on Sand Lake Rd to right on Mutters Rd
Parcel Number
26992
Exclusions
Sellers Personal
Legal Description
S21/RT39N/R09W Sunset Point Lot 32
Listing Brokerage
Edina Realty, Inc. - Spooner

Room Details

Room Area Dimensions Level Flooring
Bathroom 30 sq ft 6 x 5 Main Laminate
Bedroom 72 sq ft 9 x 8 Main Carpet
Bedroom 72 sq ft 9 x 8 Main Carpet
Kitchen 42 sq ft 7 x 6 Main Laminate
Living Room 84 sq ft 12 x 7 Main Wood

Price & Listing History

  • Aug 2018 · Listed
    $26,500
  • Aug 2018 · Sold · 1 day on market
    $26,500
  • May 2019 · Listed
    $134,900
    +409.1% above last sale $26,500 in 2018 (+$108,400 over 0.8 years · +705.0% per year)
  • Jul 2019 · Sold · 51 days on market
    $132,500
    +475.2% per year from prior sale 0.9 years earlier
  • Apr 2026 · Listed
    $187,500
    +41.5% above last sale $132,500 in 2019 (+$55,000 over 6.8 years · +5.3% per year)
  • Pending · 34 days since listed
    Final price disclosed at closing
Annualized appreciation: +475.2% per year from 2018 to 2019 (0.9 years — $26,500 → $132,500)

Prior price and listing information from sources believed to be reliable, but no guarantees of accuracy and data has not been confirmed. Please confirm with county official documents.

Flood Zone

FEMA flood mapping not available for this location
Common in rural areas where detailed floodplain studies have not yet been completed. Absence of mapping is not a determination of flood risk either way.

Source: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer. Flood maps are updated periodically (typically every 5–10 years per area) and may not reflect current ground conditions or recent improvements. For mortgage purposes, your lender may obtain an official Flood Determination from a licensed firm. Always verify before making decisions.

Location

  • Parks
  • Hospital

What's Near 5714 N Mutters Rd, Stone Lake, WI 54876

Nearby Parks

Nearby Boat Landings

Nearby Bike Trails

Local Spotlight

Stone Lake Area Schools

Hayward Community School District

School assignments are sourced from public data and may change. Confirm directly with the district before relying on assignment.

Stone Lake Property Taxes

Annual tax
$575.84 (2025)
Parcel #
26992
County
Sawyer

Legal: S21/RT39N/R09W Sunset Point Lot 32

Mortgage Calculator

Estimated monthly $0
Principal & interest
$0
Property tax (est.)
$0
Home insurance (est.)
$0

Estimate only. Insurance assumed at 0.4% of home price annually; property tax from MLS data when available, otherwise 1.5%. Not a loan offer — confirm with your lender.

More Homes in Stone Lake

15403W Allendale Lane
$269,900
15403W Allendale Lane, Stone Lake, WI 54876
2 bd · 2 ba · 1,037 sqft
6874N Victory Heights Circle
$899,000
6874N Victory Heights Circle, Stone Lake, WI 54876
3 bd · 2 ba · 2,260 sqft
N5909 Lake Road
$1,100,000
N5909 Lake Road, Stone Lake, WI 54876
3 bd · 3 ba · 3,814 sqft
14443W & 14447W Court Oreilles Lake Drive
$1,850,000
14443W & 14447W Court Oreilles Lake Drive, WI 54843
3 bd · 3 ba · 3,107 sqft
14323 Court Oreilles Lake Drive
$1,400,000
14323 Court Oreilles Lake Drive, Hayward, WI 54843
5 bd · 4 ba · 3,427 sqft
3600 Boxing Camp Trail
$1,299,000
3600 Boxing Camp Trail, Stone Lake, WI 54876
4 bd · 3 ba · 3,554 sqft

This website is a service of 1 Reason Realty, a broker participant of the Northwestern Wisconsin MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.