8728 W Elephant Rock Road Hayward WI 54843 $795,000 Schedule Tour
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI Waterfront
1 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 2 Waterfront
2 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 3 Waterfront
3 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 4 Waterfront
4 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 5 Waterfront
5 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 6 Waterfront
6 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 7 Waterfront
7 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 8 Waterfront
8 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 9 Waterfront
9 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 10 Waterfront
10 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 11 Waterfront
11 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 12 Waterfront
12 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 13 Waterfront
13 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 14 Waterfront
14 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 15 Waterfront
15 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 16 Waterfront
16 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 17 Waterfront
17 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 18 Waterfront
18 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 19 Waterfront
19 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 20 Waterfront
20 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 21 Waterfront
21 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 22 Waterfront
22 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 23 Waterfront
23 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 24 Waterfront
24 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 25 Waterfront
25 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 26 Waterfront
26 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 27 Waterfront
27 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 28 Waterfront
28 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 29 Waterfront
29 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 30 Waterfront
30 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 31 Waterfront
31 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 32 Waterfront
32 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 33 Waterfront
33 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 34 Waterfront
34 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 35 Waterfront
35 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 36 Waterfront
36 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 37 Waterfront
37 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 38 Waterfront
38 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 39 Waterfront
39 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 40 Waterfront
40 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 41 Waterfront
41 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 42 Waterfront
42 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 43 Waterfront
43 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 44 Waterfront
44 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 45 Waterfront
45 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 46 Waterfront
46 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 47 Waterfront
47 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 48 Waterfront
48 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 49 Waterfront
49 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 50 Waterfront
50 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 51 Waterfront
51 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 52 Waterfront
52 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 53 Waterfront
53 / 54
8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI — photo 54 Waterfront
54 / 54
For Sale
$795,000

8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI 54843

4 beds · 4 baths · 3,248 sqft · $245/sqft · 13 acres · Built 2005 · 2-car garage

MLS# 1599904

About 8728 W Elephant Rock Road, Hayward, WI 54843

Lost Dutchman on Teal Lake.

Turn-key, fully furnished, and already set up as a successful short-term rental, this is your chance to step right into lake life or income from day one.

Chalet-style cabin on nearly 13 acres with 200 feet of low-level frontage and a clear view of Pine Island.

Located about 20 minutes from Hayward, this property has a strong rental history and is set up for immediate use or continued income.

The home offers 4 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms with a layout that works well for larger groups.

The main level features an open living area with a gas fireplace, along with a loft that works well as an office or reading area.

The finished walkout lower level includes a large family room set up for entertaining, with a shuffleboard table and space for cards or games.

Outside, there is a lakeside deck and blacktop driveway.

The 12.6 acres are on both sides of the road, giving you added space and a buffer from neighbors.

Teal Lake is known for its quieter setting, limited development, and consistent fishing, and it connects to Lost Land Lake for additional boating and recreation.

The property also adjoins the Chequamegon-Nicolet National Forest at the south corner, with access to miles of nearby trails.

Boating, fishing, ATV/UTV riding, snowmobiling, and hiking are all right here for year-round use.

Property Details

Style
One And One Half Story
Levels
One And One Half
Above Grade Finished
1,904 sq ft
Below Grade Finished
1,254 sq ft
Possession
Close Of Escrow
Heating
Forced Air
Cooling
Central Air
Electric
Circuit Breakers
Water
Drilled Well
Sewer
Septic Tank
Foundation
Poured
Construction
Log, Wood Siding
Appliances
Dryer, Dishwasher, Electric Water Heater, Microwave, Oven, Range, Refrigerator, Washer
Basement
Daylight, Full, Finished
Fireplace
One, Gas Log
Exterior Features
Dock
Patio & Porch
Deck, Open, Porch
Parking
Asphalt, Attached, Driveway, Garage, Garage Door Opener
Waterfront
Lake
Water Frontage
200 ft
HOA
None
School District
Hayward Community
County
Sawyer
Township
Town of Spider Lake
Directions
From Hayward: Hwy 77 East, right on Neumaier Rd, right on Elephant Rock Rd, follow Elephant Rock to the right, property on the left- sign on property.
Parcel Number
30573
Exclusions
Lp Tank, Sellers Personal
Legal Description
PRT GOVT LOT 2 LOT 13 CSM 9/60 #1853
Listing Brokerage
Pine Point Real Estate LLC

Room Details

Room Area Dimensions Level Flooring
Utility/Mechanical 63 sq ft 9 x 7 Lower Concrete
Bathroom 90 sq ft 10 x 9 Lower Ceramic Tile
Bathroom 60 sq ft 10 x 6 Upper Ceramic Tile
Office 182 sq ft 14 x 13 Upper Carpet
Bathroom 50 sq ft 10 x 5 Main Ceramic Tile
Bathroom 117 sq ft 13 x 9 Main Ceramic Tile
Laundry Room 80 sq ft 10 x 8 Main Ceramic Tile
Living Room 270 sq ft 18 x 15 Main Ceramic Tile
Kitchen 168 sq ft 14 x 12 Main Ceramic Tile
Family Room 450 sq ft 25 x 18 Lower Carpet
Dining Room 96 sq ft 12 x 8 Main Ceramic Tile
Bedroom 182 sq ft 14 x 13 Main Carpet
Bedroom 182 sq ft 14 x 13 Upper Carpet
Bedroom 156 sq ft 13 x 12 Main Carpet
Bedroom 288 sq ft 24 x 12 Lower Carpet

Price & Listing History

  • Sep 2013 · Listed
    $430,650
    8728W Elephant Rock Road
  • Jul 2014 · Sold · 299 days on market
    $215,250
    Price reduced $430,650 → $304,991 before sale
  • Apr 2026 · Listed
    $795,000
    +269.3% above last sale $215,250 in 2014 (+$579,750 over 11.8 years · +11.7% per year)
  • Currently active · 53 days on market

Prior price and listing information from sources believed to be reliable, but no guarantees of accuracy and data has not been confirmed. Please confirm with county official documents.

Flood Zone

FEMA flood mapping not available for this location
Common in rural areas where detailed floodplain studies have not yet been completed. Absence of mapping is not a determination of flood risk either way.

Source: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer. Flood maps are updated periodically (typically every 5–10 years per area) and may not reflect current ground conditions or recent improvements. For mortgage purposes, your lender may obtain an official Flood Determination from a licensed firm. Always verify before making decisions.

About Teal Lake

This property is on Teal Lake, a lake in Sawyer County.

Surface area
1,024 acres
Max depth
31 ft

Public access: Public boat access available.

Fish species:
Musky Panfish Largemouth Bass Smallmouth Bass Northern Pike Walleye
No aquatic invasive species reported in WI DNR monitoring records.

View Teal Lake on the WI DNR lake portal →

Source: Wisconsin DNR · lake data as of May 2026. Lake information is provided for general reference only and may not reflect current conditions. Verify independently before making decisions.

Location

  • Parks
  • Boat landings
  • Bike trails

What's Near 8728 W Elephant Rock Rd, Hayward, WI 54843

Nearby Parks

Nearby Boat Landings

Nearby Bike Trails

Hayward Area Schools

Hayward Community School District

Elementary
Hayward Primary (PK-02)
Middle
Hayward Middle (06-08)
High
Hayward High (09-12)

School information is sourced from public NCES data (assigned public schools from attendance-boundary data; nearby private schools and colleges by distance) and may change. Confirm directly with the school or district before relying on it.

Hayward Property Taxes

Annual tax
$4,852.13 (2025)
Parcel #
30573
County
Sawyer

Legal: PRT GOVT LOT 2 LOT 13 CSM 9/60 #1853

Mortgage Calculator

Estimated monthly $0
Principal & interest
$0
Property tax (est.)
$0
Home insurance (est.)
$0

Estimate only. Insurance assumed at 0.4% of home price annually; property tax from MLS data when available, otherwise 1.5%. Not a loan offer — confirm with your lender.

More Homes near 8728 W Elephant Rock Rd Hayward, WI 54843

8182 W Nowak Road
$254,000
8182 W Nowak Road, Hayward, WI 54843
1 bd
13080 N Red Deer Road
$675,000
13080 N Red Deer Road, Hayward, WI 54843
3 bd · 2 ba · 2,688 sqft
11020 Allan Road
$89,000
11020 Allan Road, Hayward, WI 54843
1 bd · 1 ba · 243 sqft
10562 N Forest Circle Drive
$539,900
10562 N Forest Circle Drive, Hayward, WI 54843
2 bd · 1 ba · 1,893 sqft
6856W Wolf Island Road
$380,000
6856W Wolf Island Road, Hayward, WI 54843
2 bd · 1 ba · 3,860 sqft
11165 W Elaine Drive 8
$249,900
11165 W Elaine Drive 8, Hayward, WI 54843
2 bd · 2 ba · 974 sqft
11165 W Elaine Drive 7
$279,900
11165 W Elaine Drive 7, Hayward, WI 54843
2 bd · 2 ba · 1,010 sqft
11165 W Elaine Drive 6
$269,900
11165 W Elaine Drive 6, Hayward, WI 54843
2 bd · 2 ba · 1,120 sqft
11404 N Farnsworth Road
$599,000
11404 N Farnsworth Road, Hayward, WI 54843
3 bd · 1 ba · 1,192 sqft
9724 N County Highway A
$849,900
9724 N County Highway A, Hayward, WI 54843
4 bd · 5 ba · 7,963 sqft
10696 W Otter Lane
$575,000
10696 W Otter Lane, Hayward, WI 54843
3 bd · 2 ba · 2,035 sqft
11495 W Tiger Cat Road
$335,900
11495 W Tiger Cat Road, Hayward, WI 54843
2 bd · 1 ba · 522 sqft

This website is a service of 1 Reason Realty, a broker participant of the Northwestern Wisconsin MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.