584 21 1/2 Avenue, Cumberland, WI 54829

4 beds · 2 baths (1 Full / 1 Half) · 2,425 sqft · $117/sqft · 0.85 acres · Built 1940

MLS# 1597988

Listed Jan 22, 2026

About 584 21 1/2 Avenue, Cumberland, WI 54829

Welcome home to this beautifully refreshed 4-bedroom, 2-bath property, perfectly situated in a peaceful country setting just minutes from schools, parks, downtown amenities, and local trails.

You’ll be amazed at how private and quiet this location feels while still offering the convenience of town nearby.

Inside, you’ll find a thoughtfully updated home featuring an inviting open-concept floor plan that seamlessly connects the kitchen and spacious dining area—perfect for everyday living, holiday gatherings, and entertaining guests.

The stunning sunken living room provides a warm and welcoming space to relax, while the charming three-season porch with its cozy fireplace creates the perfect spot for family get-togethers or quiet evenings.

Recent improvements include a new furnace, updated appliances, and spray-foam insulation added to the main-level exterior walls, the upstairs bathroom, and the south bedroom, enhancing both comfort and energy efficiency.

A newly added main-floor laundry room offers the convenience today’s buyers are looking for.

Outside, the detached 3-car garage provides plenty of space for vehicles, storage, hobbies, or recreational toys.

Combining modern updates, generous living spaces, and an exceptionally peaceful setting, this property is ready for you to call it home.

Property Details

Listing Brokerage: Dane Arthur Real Estate Agency/Turtle Lake

Price & Listing History

Jun 2025 · Listed

$150,000
Aug 2025 · Sold · 66 days on market

$130,000
Jan 2026 · Listed

$349,900

+169.2% above last sale $130,000 in 2025 (+$219,900 over 0.4 years · +872.3% per year)
Currently active · 227 days on market

Now $284,900
Aug 2026 · Listed

$299,900

+130.7% above last sale $130,000 in 2025 (+$169,900 over 1.0 years · +135.8% per year)
Currently active · 30 days on market

Prior price and listing information from sources believed to be reliable, but no guarantees of accuracy and data has not been confirmed. Please confirm with county official documents.

Location

Cumberland Area Schools

Cumberland School District

School information is sourced from public NCES data (assigned public schools from attendance-boundary data; nearby private schools and colleges by distance) and may change. Confirm directly with the school or district before relying on it.