12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 $480,000 Schedule Tour
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image1 Under Contract
1 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image2 Under Contract
2 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image3 Under Contract
3 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image4 Under Contract
4 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image5 Under Contract
5 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image6 Under Contract
6 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image7 Under Contract
7 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image8 Under Contract
8 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image9 Under Contract
9 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image10 Under Contract
10 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image11 Under Contract
11 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image12 Under Contract
12 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image13 Under Contract
13 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image14 Under Contract
14 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image15 Under Contract
15 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image16 Under Contract
16 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image17 Under Contract
17 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image18 Under Contract
18 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image19 Under Contract
19 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image20 Under Contract
20 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image21 Under Contract
21 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image22 Under Contract
22 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image23 Under Contract
23 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image24 Under Contract
24 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image25 Under Contract
25 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image26 Under Contract
26 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image27 Under Contract
27 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image28 Under Contract
28 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image29 Under Contract
29 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image30 Under Contract
30 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image31 Under Contract
31 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image32 Under Contract
32 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image33 Under Contract
33 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image34 Under Contract
34 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image35 Under Contract
35 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image36 Under Contract
36 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image37 Under Contract
37 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image38 Under Contract
38 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image39 Under Contract
39 / 40
12503 Small Road Hayward WI 54843 - image40 Under Contract
40 / 40
Under Contract
$480,000

12503 N Small Road, Hayward, WI 54843

2 beds · 1 bath · 2,688 sqft · $179/sqft · 0.7 acres · Built 2001 · 1-car garage

MLS# 1600430

About 12503 N Small Road, Hayward, WI 54843

Waterfront Living with Room to Grow! Enjoy year-round lake living in this inviting 2-bedroom home with a den/optional 3rd bedroom, offering the perfect blend of comfort, recreation, and future potential.

The 1344 sq.

ft.

main floor features an open-concept kitchen and living area, complete with a cozy wood burning fireplace—ideal for gathering and relaxing.

Convenient laundry room on main as well.

Step out from the dining area onto the expansive deck overlooking the beautiful blue water, perfect for grilling, entertaining, or simply enjoying peaceful lake views.

Low elevation to 100 ft of swimmable frontage, dock included, plus ample space to add a boat lift.

There is potential for up to an additional 1344 sq ft (currently unfinished walkout basement) providing excellent opportunity to expand your living space; plumbed for a 2nd bath, with room for an additional bedroom and family/rec.

room.

The tuck under 1 car garage if kept, is great for storage for a boat, trailer, lake toys, or side-by-side.

Easily add a wall and fire barrier to block off the garage.

See supplements for a list of included and negotiable items.

Located next to seldom used small public boat launch (no parking avail.)—primarily used by neighbors, helps maintain a quiet and peaceful setting.

The property also includes a newer storage shed in front for lake equipment and an additional shed in the back for lawn care, etc.

Need a bigger garage? Zoning indicates potential to add an additional garage near the home with access driveway off of Small Rd.

Outdoor enthusiasts will love the proximity to Gerlach Boat Landing, excellent fishing and full recreation on Nelson Lake, plus direct access to snowmobile and UTV trails right from the property.

An excellent opportunity to own a versatile and scenic waterfront home ready for its next chapter!

Property Details

Style
One Story
Stories
1
Levels
One
Above Grade Finished
1,344 sq ft
Lot Dimensions
334 x 98 x 344 x 100
Possession
Close Of Escrow
Heating
Forced Air
Cooling
Central Air
Electric
Circuit Breakers
Water
Drilled Well, Private, Well
Sewer
Septic Tank
Foundation
Poured
Construction
Vinyl Siding
Appliances
Microwave, Oven, Range, Refrigerator, Range Hood
Interior Features
Ceiling Fans
Windows
Window Coverings
Basement
Full, Walk Out Access
Fireplace
One, Wood Burning
Exterior Features
Dock
Patio & Porch
Deck
Parking
Driveway, Gravel, Garage Door Opener
Other Structures
Sheds
Waterfront
Lake
Water Frontage
100 ft
View
Water
HOA
None
School District
Hayward Community
County
Sawyer
Township
Town of Lenroot
Directions
From Hayward: Take Hwy 63 N to Nelson Lake Rd and Turn Left, Take Right on Tanning Point Rd, Right on Small Rd, Left at #12503.
Parcel Number
15964
Original List Price
$525,000
Previous Price
$490,000
Exclusions
Sellers Personal
Legal Description
S25-T42-R09W SKEETERS POINT ADDN LOT 2
Listing Brokerage
Route 63 Realty LLC

Price & Listing History

  • May 2026 · Listed
    $525,000
  • Under Contract · 190 days since listed
    Final price disclosed at closing

Prior price and listing information from sources believed to be reliable, but no guarantees of accuracy and data has not been confirmed. Please confirm with county official documents.

About Nelson Lake

This property is on Nelson Lake, a lake in Sawyer County.

Surface area
2,716 acres
Max depth
33 ft

Public access: Public boat access available.

Fish species:
Panfish Largemouth Bass Smallmouth Bass Northern Pike Walleye
Aquatic invasive species present: Banded Mystery Snail, Chinese Mystery Snail, Ornamental water lilies (non-native Nymphaea sp.), Rusty Crayfish

View Nelson Lake on the WI DNR lake portal →

Source: Wisconsin DNR · lake data as of May 2026. Lake information is provided for general reference only and may not reflect current conditions. Verify independently before making decisions.

Location

What's Near 12503 N Small Rd, Hayward, WI 54843

Local Spotlight

Hayward Area Schools

Hayward Community School District

Elementary
Hayward Primary (PK-02)
Middle
Hayward Middle (06-08)
High
Hayward High (09-12)

Nearby private schools

  • Northern Lights Christian Academy 5.9 mi · Hayward

School information is sourced from public NCES data (assigned public schools from attendance-boundary data; nearby private schools and colleges by distance) and may change. Confirm directly with the school or district before relying on it.

Hayward Property Taxes

Annual tax
$2,807.42 (2025)
Parcel #
15964
County
Sawyer

Mortgage Calculator

Estimated monthly $0
Principal & interest
$0
Property tax (est.)
$0
Home insurance (est.)
$0

Estimate only. Insurance assumed at 0.4% of home price annually; property tax from MLS data when available, otherwise 1.5%. Not a loan offer — confirm with your lender.

More Homes near 12503 N Small Rd Hayward, WI 54843

This website is a service of 1 Reason Realty, a broker participant of the Northwestern Wisconsin MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.