12141N Pine Hollow Trail Hayward WI 54843 $995,000 Schedule Tour
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image1 Waterfront
1 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image2 Waterfront
2 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image3 Waterfront
3 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image4 Waterfront
4 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image5 Waterfront
5 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image6 Waterfront
6 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image7 Waterfront
7 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image8 Waterfront
8 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image9 Waterfront
9 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image10 Waterfront
10 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image11 Waterfront
11 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image12 Waterfront
12 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image13 Waterfront
13 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image14 Waterfront
14 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image15 Waterfront
15 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image16 Waterfront
16 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image17 Waterfront
17 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image18 Waterfront
18 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image19 Waterfront
19 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image20 Waterfront
20 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image21 Waterfront
21 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image22 Waterfront
22 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image23 Waterfront
23 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image24 Waterfront
24 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image25 Waterfront
25 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image26 Waterfront
26 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image27 Waterfront
27 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image28 Waterfront
28 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image29 Waterfront
29 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image30 Waterfront
30 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image31 Waterfront
31 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image32 Waterfront
32 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image33 Waterfront
33 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image34 Waterfront
34 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image35 Waterfront
35 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image36 Waterfront
36 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image37 Waterfront
37 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image38 Waterfront
38 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image39 Waterfront
39 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image40 Waterfront
40 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image41 Waterfront
41 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image42 Waterfront
42 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image43 Waterfront
43 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image44 Waterfront
44 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image45 Waterfront
45 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image46 Waterfront
46 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image47 Waterfront
47 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image48 Waterfront
48 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image49 Waterfront
49 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image50 Waterfront
50 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image51 Waterfront
51 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image52 Waterfront
52 / 53
12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward WI 54843 - Residential house for sale - MLS #1604753 - image53 Waterfront
53 / 53
For Sale
$995,000

12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward, WI 54843

5 beds · 3 baths · 3,021 sqft · $329/sqft · 3.08 acres · Built 2023

MLS# 1604753

About 12141N Pine Hollow Trail, Hayward, WI 54843

Exceptional craftsmanship, privacy and beautiful water views come together at this custom-built home on over 3 wooded acres with 200+ feet of frontage on the Tiger Cat Flowage.

Built in 2023 by highly regarded Keenan Construction, this 5-bedroom, 3-bath home offers approximately 2,900 finished sq ft with quality evident throughout, including spray foam insulation, LP SmartSide siding and carefully selected finishes and fixtures.

Vaulted ceilings and abundant lake-facing windows showcase peaceful southwesterly views from the open main living area.

The kitchen features beautiful hickory cabinetry, Cambria quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances and a large center island, while a stone-surround LP gas fireplace creates an inviting focal point in the living room.

The lake-facing primary suite offers a spacious walk-in closet and private bath with double vanities and tile shower.

Main-floor laundry adds everyday convenience.

The walkout lower level is equally impressive, with 4 additional bedrooms, a spacious family room, second stone-surround gas fireplace and mini kitchenette with sink and cabinetry—ideal for family and guests.

Outside, enjoy the lake-facing deck, firepit area, expansive yard and gradual approach to the waterfront.

A dock is included, providing boating access throughout the Tiger Cat Flowage, well known for excellent fishing and its annual musky and largemouth bass tournaments.

A detached 2-car garage and ample parking provide room for boats, trailers and recreational toys.

The Wheel Inn has great food and is within easy walking distance for dinner or drinks.

The direct snowmobile trail access, a nearby ATV trail and a location only about 20 minutes from Hayward complete this exceptional Northwoods property.

Pontoon, kayaks, and furnishings are negotiable.

Property Details

Style
One Story
Stories
1
Levels
One
Above Grade Finished
1,511 sq ft
Below Grade Finished
1,381 sq ft
Possession
Close Of Escrow
Heating
Forced Air
Cooling
Central Air
Electric
Circuit Breakers
Water
Drilled Well
Sewer
Septic Tank
Foundation
Poured
Appliances
Dryer, Dishwasher, Microwave, Oven, Range, Refrigerator, Washer
Windows
Window Coverings
Basement
Finished, Walk Out Access
Fireplace
Two, Gas Log
Exterior Features
Dock
Patio & Porch
Composite, Concrete, Deck, Patio
Parking
Driveway, Detached, Garage, Gravel
Waterfront
Yes
Water Frontage
204 ft
View
Lake
HOA
None
School District
Hayward Community
County
Sawyer
Township
Town of Spider Lake
Directions
From Hayward, go east on Hwy 77 approx. 12 miles to Wheel Inn Drive. Turn right on Wheel Inn Drive and follow around the corner to right on Pine Hollow Trail. Property is the first driveway on the left.
Parcel Number
31313
Exclusions
Lp Tank, Sellers Personal
Listing Brokerage
Northwest Wisconsin Realty Team

Location

  • Parks
  • Bike trails

What's Near 12141N Pine Hollow Trl, Hayward, WI 54843

Nearby Parks

Nearby Boat Landings

Nearby Bike Trails

Local Spotlight

Hayward Area Schools

Hayward Community School District

School information is sourced from public NCES data (assigned public schools from attendance-boundary data; nearby private schools and colleges by distance) and may change. Confirm directly with the school or district before relying on it.

Hayward Property Taxes

Annual tax
$5,223.26 (2025)
Parcel #
31313
County
Sawyer

Mortgage Calculator

Estimated monthly $0
Principal & interest
$0
Property tax (est.)
$0
Home insurance (est.)
$0

Estimate only. Insurance assumed at 0.4% of home price annually; property tax from MLS data when available, otherwise 1.5%. Not a loan offer — confirm with your lender.

More Homes near 12141N Pine Hollow Trl Hayward, WI 54843

11758 W Paddock Road
$199,900
11758 W Paddock Road, Hayward, WI 54843
1 bd · 1 ba · 1,800 sqft
11776 N Lower Twin Lake Road
$239,900
11776 N Lower Twin Lake Road, Hayward, WI 54843
2 bd · 1 ba · 1,181 sqft
$274,900
12115W Twin Lake Road, Hayward, WI 54843
3 bd · 2 ba · 2,304 sqft
12434 W Bethel Road
$345,900
12434 W Bethel Road, Hayward, WI 54843
3 bd · 2 ba · 2,004 sqft
11165 W Elaine Drive 5
$249,900
11165 W Elaine Drive 5, Hayward, WI 54843
2 bd · 2 ba · 1,184 sqft
$279,900
11165 Elaine Drive, Hayward, WI 54843
2 bd · 2 ba · 1,010 sqft
12629 W State Highway 77
$549,900
12629 W State Highway 77, Hayward, WI 54843
3 bd · 3 ba · 2,488 sqft
12558 Twin Lake Road
$1,250,000
12558 Twin Lake Road, Hayward, WI 54843
3 bd · 3 ba · 2,872 sqft
11147N Blue Heron Lane
$699,500
11147N Blue Heron Lane , Hayward, WI 54843
3 bd · 4 ba · 2,520 sqft
11263 Songbird Lane
$299,000
11263 Songbird Lane, Hayward, WI 54843
3 bd · 2 ba · 2,040 sqft
$289,900
11495 Tiger Cat Road, Hayward, WI 54843
2 bd · 1 ba · 522 sqft
10976 W Crane Lane
$777,000
10976 W Crane Lane, Hayward, WI 54843
3 bd · 3 ba · 2,188 sqft

This website is a service of 1 Reason Realty, a broker participant of the Northwestern Wisconsin MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.