10634 Kansas Avenue Hayward, WI 54843
6 beds · 4 baths (3 Full / 1 Half) · 6,600 sqft · $105/sqft · 0.89 acres · Built 1887
MLS# 1600356
About 10634 Kansas Avenue
Steeped in Hayward history and overlooking Shue’s Pond, this iconic Victorian—known as the McCormick House—offers a rare blend of timeless architecture and modern functionality.
Originally built in the late 1800s, the home showcases classic Queen Anne design with its striking turret, intricate woodwork, and expansive covered porch that welcomes you in with undeniable character.
Inside, you’ll find beautifully preserved details paired with thoughtful updates.
Spacious gathering areas feature hardwood floors, abundant natural light, and warm, inviting finishes.
The main level offers multiple living and dining spaces ideal for entertaining, while the custom bar area and large dining room create a natural setting for hosting.
A fully equipped commercial kitchen provides exceptional flexibility for events, catering, or continued hospitality use.
Upstairs, numerous well-appointed bedrooms and updated bathrooms offer comfort and privacy for guests or residents alike.
The layout supports a variety of living arrangements, whether as a private residence, investment property, or continued bed-and-breakfast operation.
Set on a generous lot with manicured grounds, outdoor seating areas, and views of the water, the property delivers both presence and versatility.
Its prime location near downtown Hayward places shops, dining, and recreation just moments away.
A truly one-of-a-kind opportunity to own a landmark property with both historic significance and income potential.
Property Details
- Style
- Two Story
- Stories
- 2
- Levels
- Two
- Above Grade Finished
- 4,400 sq ft
- Below Grade Finished
- 200 sq ft
- Possession
- Close Of Escrow
- Heating
- Radiant
- Cooling
- Central Air
- Electric
- Circuit Breakers
- Water
- Public
- Sewer
- Public Sewer
- Foundation
- Stone
- Construction
- Wood Siding
- Appliances
- Gas Water Heater, Other, See Remarks
- Basement
- Full
- Fireplace
- Two, Gas Log
- Patio & Porch
- Deck, Open, Patio, Porch
- Parking
- No Driveway, No Garage
- Other Structures
- Sheds
- HOA
- None
- School District
- Hayward Community
- County
- Sawyer
- Township
- City of Hayward
- Directions
- Turn onto Kansas Avenue off of US Highway 63. Property is on right side across from pond. Fire #10634
- Parcel Number
- 38048
- Exclusions
- Other-See Remarks
- Legal Description
- ORG PLAT LOTS 1-6 BLK 13, LOT 1 CSM 28/106 #7217, INC PRT VCT ALY ADJ TO LOTS 4-6, S22/T41N/R9W
- Listing Brokerage
- Area North Realty Inc
Room Details
| Room | Area | Dimensions | Level | Flooring |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dining Area | 304 sq ft | 19 x 16 | Main | Wood |
| Bathroom | 42 sq ft | 7 x 6 | Main | Tile |
| Bathroom | 30 sq ft | 6 x 5 | Main | Tile |
| Office | 78 sq ft | 13 x 6 | Main | Wood |
| Living Room | 420 sq ft | 28 x 15 | Main | Wood |
| Kitchen | 165 sq ft | 15 x 11 | Main | Wood |
| Dining Area | 420 sq ft | 28 x 15 | Main | Wood |
| Other | 221 sq ft | 17 x 13 | Main | Wood |
| Bedroom | 225 sq ft | 15 x 15 | Upper | Carpet |
| Bedroom | 180 sq ft | 15 x 12 | Upper | Carpet |
| Bedroom | 252 sq ft | 21 x 12 | Upper | Carpet |
| Bedroom | 288 sq ft | 24 x 12 | Upper | Carpet |
Price & Listing History
-
Apr 2011 · Listed$899,000
-
Jun 2017 · Sold · 2260 days on market$370,000Price reduced $899,000 → $475,000 before sale
-
Dec 2023 · Listed$475,000+28.4% above last sale $370,000 in 2017 (+$105,000 over 6.5 years · +3.9% per year)
-
Mar 2024 · Sold · 81 days on market$521,000+5.2% per year from prior sale 6.8 years earlier
-
May 2026 · Listed$695,000+33.4% above last sale $521,000 in 2024 (+$174,000 over 2.1 years · +14.4% per year)
-
Currently active · 18 days on market
Prior price and listing information from sources believed to be reliable, but no guarantees of accuracy and data has not been confirmed. Please confirm with county official documents.
Flood Zone
Source: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer. Flood maps are updated periodically (typically every 5–10 years per area) and may not reflect current ground conditions or recent improvements. For mortgage purposes, your lender may obtain an official Flood Determination from a licensed firm. Always verify before making decisions.
Location
- Parks
- Boat landings
- Bike trails
- Grocery
- Hospital
- Gas
- Schools
What's Near 10634 Kansas Ave, Hayward, WI 54843
Nearby Parks
- 0.1 mi
- 2.4 mi
- 2.4 mi
Nearby Boat Landings
- 5.5 mi
- 8.6 mi
- 10.6 mi
Nearby Bike Trails
- 2.5 mi
- 2.5 mi
- 2.6 mi
Local Spotlight
- 0.8 mi
Hayward Area Schools
Hayward Community School District
School assignments are sourced from public data and may change. Confirm directly with the district before relying on assignment.
Hayward Property Taxes
- Annual tax
- $5,727.49 (2025)
- Parcel #
38048- County
- Sawyer
Legal: ORG PLAT LOTS 1-6 BLK 13, LOT 1 CSM 28/106 #7217, INC PRT VCT ALY ADJ TO LOTS 4-6, S22/T41N/R9W
Mortgage Calculator
More Homes in Hayward
