Residentialhouse for sale picture with an address of 1875 Pine Island Park Street in Balsam Lake and a list price of 1225000 Waterfront
1 / 54
Waterfront
2 / 54
Waterfront
3 / 54
Waterfront
4 / 54
Waterfront
5 / 54
Waterfront
6 / 54
Waterfront
7 / 54
Waterfront
8 / 54
Waterfront
9 / 54
Waterfront
10 / 54
Waterfront
11 / 54
Waterfront
12 / 54
Waterfront
13 / 54
Waterfront
14 / 54
Waterfront
15 / 54
Waterfront
16 / 54
Waterfront
17 / 54
Waterfront
18 / 54
Waterfront
19 / 54
Waterfront
20 / 54
Waterfront
21 / 54
Waterfront
22 / 54
Waterfront
23 / 54
Waterfront
24 / 54
Waterfront
25 / 54
Waterfront
26 / 54
Waterfront
27 / 54
Waterfront
28 / 54
Waterfront
29 / 54
Waterfront
30 / 54
Waterfront
31 / 54
Waterfront
32 / 54
Waterfront
33 / 54
Waterfront
34 / 54
Waterfront
35 / 54
Waterfront
36 / 54
Waterfront
37 / 54
Waterfront
38 / 54
Waterfront
39 / 54
Waterfront
40 / 54
Waterfront
41 / 54
Waterfront
42 / 54
Waterfront
43 / 54
Waterfront
44 / 54
Waterfront
45 / 54
Waterfront
46 / 54
Waterfront
47 / 54
Waterfront
48 / 54
Waterfront
49 / 54
Waterfront
50 / 54
Waterfront
51 / 54
Waterfront
52 / 54
Waterfront
53 / 54
Waterfront
54 / 54
For Sale
$1,225,000

1875 Pine Island Park Street Balsam Lake, WI 54810

3 beds · 2 baths · 2,156 sqft · $568/sqft · 11 acres · Built 1965

MLS# 1601077

About 1875 Pine Island Park Street

Nestled along the shores of highly sought-after Boston Bay on Balsam Lake, this rustic retreat blends timeless cabin charm with thoughtful modern updates.

Set on over 11 wooded acres with 115 feet of frontage on Balsam Lake, this cozy cabin in the woods offers privacy, tranquility, and endless possibilities.

The property includes three parcel IDs, one of which is a separate 5-acre buildable lot.

Originally built in 1965 and extensively remodeled in 2015, the home was lifted to add a new basement while nearly every aspect of the property was refreshed, including new windows, siding (treated with Ecowood to give the appearance of aged wood), septic system, mechanics, plumbing, wiring, kitchen, and beautiful rustic finishes throughout.

Inside, you’ll find warm character at every turn, from the custom reclaimed barnwood front door to the reclaimed wood kitchen cabinetry and stairway.

Rustic 9” white pine plank flooring adds to the authentic Northwoods feel.

The lower-level walkout leads directly to your peaceful lakeside setting, where a stunning dry creek bed flows from the rain garden, creating a truly serene outdoor environment.

A 2-car garage, also added in 2015, completes this exceptional lake property.

If you’ve been searching for peaceful serenity on Balsam Lake, this is it.

Property Details

Style
One Story
Stories
1
Levels
One
Above Grade Finished
993 sq ft
Below Grade Finished
1,027 sq ft
Possession
Close Of Escrow
Heating
Forced Air
Cooling
Central Air
Electric
Circuit Breakers
Water
Sand Point Well, Well
Sewer
Septic Tank
Foundation
Block
Construction
Metal Siding, Wood Siding
Appliances
Dryer, Dishwasher, Oven, Range, Refrigerator, Range Hood, Washer
Basement
Full, Finished
Exterior Features
Dock
Patio & Porch
Deck
Parking
Driveway, Detached, Garage, Gravel
Waterfront
Lake
Water Frontage
115 ft
View
Lake
HOA
None
School District
Unity
County
Polk
Township
Town of Milltown
Directions
From the town of Balsam Lake take Hwy 46 N to Right on 200th Ave to Right on 140th St to Right on Pine Island Park Street to the property on your Right. Long driveway to the lake.
Parcel Number
040011900000
Listing Brokerage
Edina Realty, Corp. - St Croix Falls

Room Details

Room Area Dimensions Level Flooring
Laundry Room 18 sq ft 6 x 3 Lower
Pantry 30 sq ft 6 x 5 Main
Bedroom 132 sq ft 12 x 11 Lower
Bedroom 270 sq ft 18 x 15 Lower
Bedroom 140 sq ft 14 x 10 Main Wood
Kitchen 153 sq ft 17 x 9 Main Wood
Family Room 208 sq ft 16 x 13 Lower
Living Room 420 sq ft 20 x 21 Main Wood

Price & Listing History

  • Feb 2026 · Listed
    $1,225,000
  • Under Contract · 86 days since listed
    Final price disclosed at closing

Prior price and listing information from sources believed to be reliable, but no guarantees of accuracy and data has not been confirmed. Please confirm with county official documents.

Flood Zone

Not in a Special Flood Hazard Area · FEMA Zone X
AREA OF MINIMAL FLOOD HAZARD
Federally-backed mortgages do not require flood insurance for properties in this zone.

Source: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer. Flood maps are updated periodically (typically every 5–10 years per area) and may not reflect current ground conditions or recent improvements. For mortgage purposes, your lender may obtain an official Flood Determination from a licensed firm. Always verify before making decisions.

About Balsam Lake

This property is on Balsam Lake, a lake in Polk County.

Surface area
1,901 acres
Max depth
37 ft

Public access: Public boat access available.

Fish species:
Panfish Largemouth Bass Northern Pike Walleye
Aquatic invasive species present: Chinese Mystery Snail, Curly-Leaf Pondweed, Eurasian Water-Milfoil, Japanese knotweed (Fallopia japonica), Purple Loosestrife, Yellow Iris, Zebra Mussel

View Balsam Lake on the WI DNR lake portal →

Source: Wisconsin DNR · lake data as of May 2026. Lake information is provided for general reference only and may not reflect current conditions. Verify independently before making decisions.

Location

  • Parks
  • Bike trails
  • Grocery
  • Hospital
  • Gas
  • Schools

What's Near 1875 Pine Island Park St, Balsam Lake, WI 54810

Nearby Parks

Nearby Boat Landings

Nearby Bike Trails

Balsam Lake Area Schools

Unity School District

School assignments are sourced from public data and may change. Confirm directly with the district before relying on assignment.

Balsam Lake Property Taxes

Annual tax
$5,861.00 (2025)
Parcel #
040011900000
County
Polk

Mortgage Calculator

Estimated monthly $0
Principal & interest
$0
Property tax (est.)
$0
Home insurance (est.)
$0

Estimate only. Insurance assumed at 0.4% of home price annually; property tax from MLS data when available, otherwise 1.5%. Not a loan offer — confirm with your lender.

More Homes in Balsam Lake

699 Idlewild Street
$389,900
699 Idlewild Street, Balsam Lake, WI 54810
2 bd · 1 ba · 636 sqft
LOT 2 Wilderness Hills
$358,995
LOT 2 Wilderness Hills , Luck, WI 54853
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,491 sqft
LOT 3 Wilderness Hills
$369,000
LOT 3 Wilderness Hills , Luck, WI 54853
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,491 sqft
1695 White Ash Way C
$335,000
1695 White Ash Way C, Balsam Lake, WI 54810
2 bd · 1 ba · 864 sqft
2282 71st Street
$1,150,000
2282 71st Street, WI 54853
5 bd · 3 ba · 5,928 sqft
2254 220th Avenue
$295,000
2254 220th Avenue, St.Croix Falls, WI 54024
1 bd · 1 ba · 864 sqft

This website is a service of 1 Reason Realty, a broker participant of the Northwestern Wisconsin MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Similar Active Homes

1308 170th Avenue Balsam Lake WI 54810
$395,000
1308 170th Avenue Balsam Lake WI 54810
3 bd · 3 ba · 2,912 sqft
 2050 81st Street Balsam Lake WI 54810
$525,000
2050 81st Street Balsam Lake WI 54810
3 bd · 3 ba · 2,080 sqft
 699 Idlewild Street Balsam Lake WI 54810
$389,900
699 Idlewild Street Balsam Lake WI 54810
2 bd · 1 ba · 636 sqft
 1343 165th Avenue Balsam Lake WI 54810
$320,000
1343 165th Avenue Balsam Lake WI 54810
2 bd · 1 ba · 1,552 sqft
 1695 White Ash Way Balsam Lake WI 54810
$335,000
1695 White Ash Way Balsam Lake WI 54810
2 bd · 1 ba · 864 sqft
 1653 White Ash Lane Balsam Lake WI 54810
$785,000
1653 White Ash Lane Balsam Lake WI 54810
4 bd · 2 ba · 2,928 sqft